The Canyon Independent School District (Canyon ISD) Board of Trustees unanimously approved Superintendent Dr. Darryl Flusche’s evaluation late Monday night, capping a meeting dominated by debates over library materials and compliance with Texas Senate Bill 900 (SB 900).
After more than two hours in closed session, board member Casey Posey moved to approve Dr. Flusche’s evaluation, which was seconded by Matt Parker. The evaluation, described as favorable, reflects confidence in the superintendent’s leadership, though details remain undisclosed.
Bible Removal and Reinstatement
Before the evaluation vote, the board tackled the recent controversy surrounding the temporary removal of the Bible from Canyon ISD library shelves. The district had initially interpreted SB 900 — which prohibits library content containing sexually explicit material — to include the Bible due to certain passages. Deputy Superintendent Robyn Cramner explained the decision in correspondence with Rep. Jared Patterson (R-Frisco), noting that while the Bible met instructional requirements in classrooms, it was not initially deemed suitable for library shelves.
Rep. Patterson contested the removal in a Dec. 18, 2024, letter, arguing it was “likely illegal” under Texas law protecting religious texts in public schools. He emphasized that SB 900 was never intended to classify the Bible as sexually explicit. Following this clarification, the district reinstated the Bible, ensuring it remains accessible in libraries.
The interpretation of SB 900 as it applies to the Bible remains contentious. Legal experts suggest that categorizing the Bible as sexually explicit would face significant legal hurdles, given its religious and historical context.
Community Reaction
The Bible’s removal sparked widespread concern among community members, who expressed frustration during the meeting:
Regina Kiehne, a parent, described the removal as a “scandal” and credited students for advocating its reinstatement.
Krista and Steve Irlbeck criticized the district for equating the Bible with sexually explicit materials.
Trustee Comments
Board members acknowledged the controversy and reflected on lessons learned:
Casey Posey highlighted the importance of communication, stating, “The Bible is now back in our libraries, where it needs to be.”
Katharyn Weigand emphasized accountability, saying, “We don’t have to hide from mistakes … I am proud to serve alongside people who are willing to own where we could have done better.”
Looking Ahead
Canyon ISD officials have indicated no immediate plans to revise their approach to SB 900 but remain committed to ensuring access to religious and historical texts while continuing to review library materials for compliance.
.jpg)
