The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), helmed by Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy, is in damage control mode after a fierce debate erupted over the H-1B visa program, exposing a growing rift between traditional Trump supporters and the Big Tech-aligned newcomers in his coalition.
The controversy began when Musk and Ramaswamy voiced support for the H-1B program, which allows U.S. companies to employ foreign workers in specialized fields, often at lower costs. Ramaswamy’s impassioned defense of the program, paired with sharp criticism of American cultural priorities, ignited a political firestorm.
In a lengthy post on X, Ramaswamy argued that American culture overly rewards mediocrity, calling for a shift toward intellectual and creative excellence. “More math tutoring, fewer sleepovers,” he wrote, urging a focus on academic rigor over leisure activities.
This critique of American culture was met with swift backlash from conservatives who accused Ramaswamy of disrespecting American workers and ignoring the program’s flaws.
GOP Leaders and Base Push Back
Prominent conservative voices denounced Ramaswamy’s remarks, with commentator Auron MacIntyre arguing that prioritizing an academic elite would lead to “social suicide.” He cited South Korea’s declining birthrate as a cautionary tale of overemphasizing education.
Nikki Haley, a former Republican presidential rival, sharply rebuked Ramaswamy, emphasizing the need to invest in American workers over foreign labor. “There is nothing wrong with American workers or American culture,” she said.
Critics within the conservative movement pointed to inconsistencies in Ramaswamy’s position, highlighting his previous campaign promises to “gut” the H-1B program. Influencer Ashley St. Clair accused him of veering away from his prior stance, while Trump ally Nicole Shanahan described his cultural critique as “ridiculous and insulting.”
Elon Musk Adds Fuel to the Fire
Musk further inflamed tensions by agreeing with a post referring to Americans in derogatory terms. In an attempt to clarify, Musk compared the H-1B program to recruiting elite athletes for a sports team, emphasizing the need to attract “the top ~0.1% of engineering talent” to maintain America’s competitive edge.
Critics pushed back, pointing out that Musk’s own company, SpaceX, has strict hiring restrictions favoring U.S. citizens, raising questions about the sincerity of his stance.
Meanwhile, Musk faced additional scrutiny for implementing an algorithm update that deprioritized accounts blocked by verified users. Critics accused him of silencing dissent, particularly after several high-profile detractors of Musk’s visa position reported losing their verification status.
Trump’s Base Seeks Clarity
The debate has left many within Trump’s coalition seeking clarity. While the H-1B program has long been a contentious issue, Trump’s silence, along with that of Vice President-elect J.D. Vance, has only heightened tensions.
In 2016, Trump campaigned on curbing the program, describing it as a tool for companies to replace American workers with cheaper foreign labor. Critics, including researchers, continue to challenge the narrative of a domestic STEM worker shortage, arguing that H-1B workers are often hired as cost-saving substitutes rather than necessary complements.
Political Fallout and Next Steps
Ramaswamy attempted to downplay the controversy on Friday, posting, “Alright, back to real work today,” alongside a smiley face emoji. However, the damage appears far from contained, with members of Trump’s base expressing frustration over what they see as elitist and tone-deaf rhetoric from the DOGE leaders.
.jpg)
